Get Permission Kumari, Maurya, and Negi: Effect of patanjali yoga sutra on personality development: A randomized controlled trial


Introduction

Personality development is indispensable in the empirical world's journey of success, name, and fame.1 In the initial stage, the empirical personality, which is Prakriti (matter)- based, is developed, but sooner or later, one realizes the limitations of this personality.2 Yoga is currently only thought of asanas and pranayama or as an alternative therapy for treating illness and managing stress, diluting the fundamental essence of yoga.3, 4 The Karma Yoga (path of single action), Jnana Yoga (the understanding of self), Bhakti Yoga (Trust in the highest order), and Raja Yoga (Asana, Pranayam, Meditation) schools of thought are all included in the Yoga way of life.5 This knowledge may result in a total personality makeover on the physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual levels, strengthening one's capacity and motivation to perform to the best of one's potential.6 According to the ancient Yoga teacher Patanjali, Yoga is a method for calming the mind's mental fluctuations so that one might arrive at the core of the real. The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali describes a wise process of living that promotes balance and harmony. The complete text is 195 aphorisms (Sutras) called Patanjali Yog Sutra (PYS).5, 6, 7

The Sutras are short, concise, meaningful, experiential, and organized systematically and practically. There are lots of myths surrounding yoga.8, 9 One of the main ones is probably that practicing yoga would help one become less involved in everyday life. It is not for householders because it is often held that one must become a hermit or a saint to practice yoga or that yoga is solely for older and retired adults, not young people. Husbands worry that if their wives practice yoga, they may become disinterested in the outside world. Intellectuals and prosperous people believe that Yoga practices are useless for them.8, 9, 10 Another myth about yoga is that it requires one to modify their eating habits and switch to a bland diet. However, the goal of yoga is to obtain freedom (mentally and emotionally) and happiness; to do this, one does not have to renounce their regular life.7, 8, 9, 10 These benefits of Yoga practices are scarcely acknowledged or comprehended. The spiritual dimension adds depth to the Yoga idea of personality. Being spiritually rooted, sturdy, and strong helps to keep us firmly planted.11, 12, 13 The study evaluates the personality development or positive changes from the physical to the spiritual through the PYS.

Materials and Methods

The research scholar plans to use quantitative methods and includes structured and planned intervention methods for the experiments.

Research design

Randomized Controlled Trial

Population

The population consists of undergraduate students from Ambala, Haryana.

Sample size

Total calculated sample size consists of 200 students, 100 in each group.

Inclusion criteria

We included the participants (age – 21-25 yrs.), both gender and willing to participate in the study and physically fit for the yoga module.

Exclusion criteria

Patients had an allergy to oil application primarily through the nasal route, any severe respiratory ailments (URTI, allergic rhinitis, sinusitis, asthma), any severe psychiatric disorder (schizophrenia, mania, bipolar disorders OCD), chronic illness (diabetes mellitus, hypertension), taking medications like alpha-blockers, beta-blockers, corticosteroids, ace inhibitors, and statins, drug withdrawal syndromes (barbiturates, tranquilizers), substance abuse like alcohol ingestion and withdrawal, endocrine or metabolic disorders (hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism), pregnant & lactating women were excluded.Figure 1

Figure 1

Consort flow diagram

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/7cc3b8ff-95a9-4fe8-acaf-8871f3ebf698image1.png

Ethical Consideration

The Institutional Ethical Committee granted its ethical clearance. Participants were informed of the specifics of the study’s intervention, and their informed consent was acquired.

Structured intervention sessions

The practice of techniques given in PYSs.

Pranayama

Nadi sodhan pranayama

Bhramari pranayama

Meditation (Dhyan)

Standing balancing postures

Tools for data collection

  1. Structured questionnaire (Demographic data)

  2. Vedic Personality Inventory - The Original Personality Test, the most thoroughly investigated and validated psychological diagnostic tool based on the three Guna's is the Vedic Personality Inventory (VPI), was created by Dr. David Wolf. It has 32 for the Tamo guna, 28 for the Rajo guna, and 30 for the Sattva guna. The Sattva, Rajas, and Tamas Gunas are evaluated on a 7-point Likert-type scale by the VPI. The responses for each item in a guna's mode are added to get the Guna's score, then divided by the mode's total number of items. A higher score for each subscale denotes a stronger preponderance of that mode. The three domains have a minimum and maximum score range of 1–7. With Cronbach's alpha values ranging from 0.850 for Sattva, 0.915 for Rajas, and 0.699 for Tamas, VPI has strong internal consistency and stability.14

  3. The General Health Questionaire-28: The self-administered GHQ-28 is considered suitable for research purposes. The GHQ-28 focuses on deviations from normal function that prevent a person from engaging in their typical healthy activities. The questionnaire asks about any worrisome new phenomena that have emerged in recent weeks. It discloses the most recent mental state, indicating the presence of a potential psychiatric disorder. With a Cronbach's alpha of 0.85 and validity of 0.76, this survey has acceptable psychometric qualities and good internal consistency and reliability. 15, 16, 17

Data extraction

The data extraction was done on 1st day and the 30th day for the Yoga and control groups. After the pre-and post-intervention data collection, normality distribution was done to apply appropriate statistics.

Table 1

Demographic characteristics of participants

Groups

Gender

Yoga

Control

Female

43

61

Male

57

39

Age (Years)

21

43

27

22

11

21

23

30

25

24

16

27

Habitat

Rural

73

94

Urban

27

6

Family members

1

0

4

2

1

9

3

1

5

4

31

37

5

45

45

6

20

0

7

2

0

Table 2

Comparison of pre-post intervention descript3ive statistics

Groups

N

Pre-intervention mean

Post-intervention Mean

Age

Yoga

100

22.1900 (1.16076)

Sattva

Control

100

22.5200 (1.15889)

Control

100

30.01 (10.508)

41.94 (13.667)

Rajas

Yoga

100

37.12 (13.318)

27.68 (9.043)

Control

100

41.94 (13.966)

30.01 (10.508)

Tamas

Yoga

100

37.22 (10.669)

22.34 (10.780)

Control

100

28.20 (10.453)

28.20 (10.453)

GHQ Total score

Yoga

100

8.8400 (1.12564)

5.9200 (1.23648)

Control

100

8.8300 (1.18964)

8.8300 (1.18964)

Table 3

Post intervention test statistics for significant difference between both groups

Sattva

Tamas

GHQ Total score

Mann-Whitney U

3437.500

3228.500

591.500

Wilcoxon W

8487.500

8278.500

5641.500

Z

-3.819

-4.332

-10.912

Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

0.000*

0.000*

0.000*

Note- Mann-Whitney U test applied, GHQ -General Health Questionaire Std.- Standard, * P value significant < 0.05 level. Sig.-significant

Table 4

Post intervention difference between both groups for rajas scores

Levene's Test for Equality of Variances

t-test for Equality of Means

F

Sig.

T

Sig. (2-tailed)

Mean Difference

Std. Error Difference

95% Confidence Interval of the Difference

Lower

Upper

Rajas

0.973

0.325

-1.681

0.014*

-2.330

1.386

-5.064

0.404

Note- Independent t Test Std.- Standard, * P value significant <0.05. Sig.-significant

Statistical analysis

The Shapiro-Wilk test checked the normality of data. SPSS version 23 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL) was used for analysis. All quantitative variables were measured as mean, standard deviation, and standard error. Proportions and frequencies were described for categorical variables and compared using the Chi-square test. All applied statistical tests were measured on a two-sided significance level of p < 0.05. Independent t-test or Mann-Whitney U test was applied to explore the ―between and within-group differences among three study groups.

Results

Participants and descriptive data

Results were analyzed to treat analysis. One hundred participants were diagnosed, and the drop-out rate was nill. In the Yoga and control groups, equal (100) participants were available post-intervention.

Table 1 This table depicts the number of participants involved in both groups. A total of 100 participants were included in each group. Female/ male participants were 43 /57 % in the Yoga group and 61/39 % in the control group. It describes the frequency of participants' ages in each group. In the Yoga group, the majority (43%) of participants were 21 (years). In the control group, the majority (27%) of participants belonged to two age groups – 21 and 24 (years). Both groups had a minimum number of participants aged 22 (years). This table describes the habitat of participants. In the yoga group, (73%) majority of participants were from rural areas, and 27 % were from urban areas. In the control group, (94 %) majority of participants were from rural areas, and 6 % were from urban areas. It describes the frequency of participants' family members in both groups. Both groups had a similar 45% frequency of five family members. All participants

Data were checked for normality, which stated that age, Rajas, and total GHQ scores were normally distributed. Scores indicate that Sattva and Tamas variables were not normally distributed.

Table 2 The mean age of participants was 22.19 ± 1.16076 and 22.5200 ± 1.15889 years in theYoga and control groups, respectively. It states the descriptive statistics for all baseline data. It includes the mean and standard deviation of scores.

Mean Rajas scores for the Yoga and control groups were 30.70 ± 8.635 and 30.01 ± 10.508, respectively.

Mean Sattva scores for yoga and control groups were 37.12 ± 13.318 and 41.94 ± 13.966, respectively. Mean Tamas scores for yoga and control groups were 37.22 ± 10.669 and 28.20 ± 10.453, respectively. The total GHQ scores for the yoga and control groups were 8.8400 ± 1.12564 and 8.8300 ± 1.18964, respectively. Mean Rajas scores for the Yoga and control groups were 27.68 ± 8.635 and 30.01 ± 10.508, respectively. Mean Sattva scores for Yoga and control groups were 49.99 ± 9.043 and 41.94 ± 13.667, respectively. Mean Tamas scores for Yoga and control groups were 22.34 ± 10.780 and 28.20 ± 10.453, respectively. Mean GHQ total scores for the Yoga and control groups were 5.9200 ± 1.23648 and 8.8300 ± 1.18964, respectively.

Nonparametric (Mann-Whitney U) test was applied to Sattva, Tamas, and Total GHQ scores to measure the significant difference between both groups at baseline. For the outcome of Sattva scores, there was a statistically significant difference (Z-3.819, p-value- 0.000) between both groups. For the Tamas score, both groups had a statistically significant difference (Z-4.332, p-value- 0.064). GHQ Total scores were statistically significantly different (Z-10.912, p-value- 0.000) between both groups.

Normality distribution of post-intervention data was done in both groups. It states that Rajas' scores were normally distributed. P value was considered significant as <0.05 level. Results indicate that Sattva, Tamas, and total GHQ scores had important values <0.05, which states that scores were not normally distributed.

Sattva, Tamas, and Rajas' scores differed statistically significantly (p-value < 0.000) in both groups. GHQ Total scores were also statistically significantly different (p-value < 0.000) between both groups. (Table 3, Table 4)

We found greater improvement in the YG compared to the CG. Sattva score in YG increased dramatically from 30.70 (8.635) to 49.99 (15.137), simultaneously increasing from 30.01 (10.508) to 41.94 (13.667) in CG. Rajas' score in YG significantly reduced from 37.12 (13.318) to 27.68 (9.043) and decreased significantly from 41.94 (13.966) to 30.01 (10.508) in CG. (Table 4) Tamas's score in YG significantly reduced from 37.22 (10.669) to 22.34 (10.780), whereas it was the same as 28.20 (10.453) in CG. (Table 3)

Table 4 Based on the normal distribution of data, a parametric test (independent t-test) was applied to Rajas' scores to measure the significant difference between both groups. A statistically significant difference in participants' Rajas scores (t-1.681, 95% CI-5.064- 0.404, p-value- 0.014) was noted.

Discussion

The study evaluated the effect of PYS and Ashtanga Yoga practices on the individual's personality. We examined personality in all dimensions, from the physical to the spiritual, with the help of methods in the PYS text. As propounded in the Patanjali Yoga Sutra, Ashtanga Yoga is one concept that could cater to developing different aspects of human personality. We measured all dimensions through the Vedic personality inventory and GHQ-28. Sattva, Tamas, and Rajas' scores differed statistically significantly (p-value < 0.000) in both groups. GHQ Total scores were also statistically significantly different (p-value < 0.000) between both groups. We found greater improvement in the Yoga group compared to the control group. Sattva score in the Yoga group increased dramatically from 30.70 (8.635) to 49.99 (15.137), simultaneously increasing from 30.01 (10.508) to 41.94 (13.667) in the control group. Rajas' score in the Yoga group significantly reduced from 37.12 (13.318) to 27.68 (9.043) and decreased significantly from 41.94 (13.966) to 30.01 (10.508) in the control group. Tamas's score in the Yoga group significantly reduced from 37.22 (10.669) to 22.34 (10.780), whereas it was the same as 28.20 (10.453) in the control group.

The Gunas initially range in dominance when evaluating an individual's personality, but over time, the person's personality mostly settles on one of the Gunas.18 Eventually, though very slowly, through a sort of moral evolution, the individual's personality moves from Tamas and Rajas to Sattva, and finally, through the Gunas, moves and achieves liberation. Our study amply demonstrates this pattern of change towards an increase in Sattva and a decrease in Tamas following four weeks of Yoga practices. Human behavior is a reflection of several different Gunas working together. The ugliest side of our personalities, Tamas, is characterized by excessive sleepiness, laziness, sadness, procrastination, powerlessness, impulsivity, rage, and arrogance (filled with life energy). To move towards Rajas (the shining one), which is characterized by intense activity, ambition, competitiveness, high self-importance, desire for sense satisfaction, lack of interest in spiritual altitude, dissatisfaction with one's position, jealousy of others, and a worldly cleverness, we must first reduce Tamas through mastery over the mind. 19 Rajas and Tamas are the outward signs of a violent mental state in which one cannot control irrational emotions and impulsive behavior. Yoga is well-known for helping to promote good health in the physical, mental, social, emotional, and spiritual realms, which leads to feeling energized, self-assured, and in control of the senses, with harmony and coordination between the right and left brain functions, and free from stress. Rajas and Tamas are the outward signs of a violent mental state in which one cannot control irrational emotions and impulsive behavior. Yoga is well known for helping to promote good health in the physical, mental,  emotional, social, and spiritual realms, which leads to feeling energized, self-assured, and in control of the senses, with harmony and coordination between the right and left brain functions, and free from stress. 20 With continued development and mastery, one enters the state of Sattva dominance, characterized by honesty, stability, discipline, and self-control. It also includes a preference for vegetarianism, sharp intelligence, honesty, gravity, dutifulness, separation, respect for superiors, staunch commitment, and stability in adversity. It also includes conscious action. As a result, it is clear that despite both Rajas and Tamas possessing both positive and negative traits, they both represent a violent mental state in which a person lacks control over their personality or the capacity to enhance some aspects of their overall health. Through Yoga, Sattva grew. Yoga can therefore be advised for its added benefits of fostering personality development because it is more in line with Indian traditional practices and is affordable.21 It is well known that exercise is linked to better cognitive results. Mounting research indicates that mind-body interventions such as yoga may have comparable effects.

Although personality is related to routine activities and cognition, it is unclear how nature plays a part in the relationship between mind-body practice and awareness. The current study investigates bidirectional temporal relationships between personality traits, mind-body training, and understanding in healthy people (N = 2051) using data from waves 2 and 3 (2004-2014) of the Midlife in the United States study. 22 Using 9,284 data samples and the Ecological Systems Theory as a foundation, This study investigated the links between teen personality qualities and physical activity, in addition to the mediating effect of peer interactions and the moderating role of parent-child relationships. The regression analysis findings demonstrate that regular physical activity considerably benefits the emergence of personality traits like neuroticism, conscientiousness, and agreeableness. 23 Sattva improved in both the yoga and control groups, with a tendency for yoga to have a higher effect size. Rajas scores were reduced in both but significantly better in the physical exercise group than in yoga, and Tamas reduced in the physical exercise group. The general health status improved in the Yoga and control groups. 24

Researchers noted significantly increased Sattva scores and reduced Rajas's and Tamas's scores in YG. The results have shown that the yoga module has improved the personality of HGs by increasing their Sattva Guna and reducing their Rajas and Tamas.21 Transcendental meditation is a technique for smoothly reducing mental activity, allowing the body to enter a deeper level of sleep while the mind stays clear and awake. Orme-Johnson et al. at the University of Texas demonstrated that mediators exhibit a higher physiological equilibrium than non-mediators. He also explained that mediators are more effective than non-mediators at maintaining this balance under pressure.25 David completed a study and found that yoga boosts personal productivity.26

Stregtnth and Limitations

We compared the findings with the control group in equal allocation. The sample size was adequate, and the drop-out rate was nill compared to other studies in the same intervention.

However, it was an open-label trial conducted in a single center. Subjective questionnaires were used to measure and compare the results. The assessed variables were self-reported in nature. Follow-up is also not executed.

Conclusion

The results have shown that Yoga practice has improved the personality of young, healthy volunteers by increasing their Sattva Guna and reducing their Rajas and Tamas. Further, yoga is cost-effective. However, to benefit from yoga, one has to adopt yoga as a life management technique. This would include the Raj Yoga practices of asana, pranayama, and meditation and imbibe the concept of Karma, Jnana and Bhakti Yoga. Such an integrated approach can yield superior results for individual happiness and performance. Hence, this study suggests a solution to calm their mind and help them to increase their Sattva Guna and improve their personality. Based on the study results, we are motivated to recommend similar experimental studies in multiple settings to refine these findings and insights further.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

A Caspi RL Shiner Personality Development3John Wiley & Sons, Inc200630065

2 

WA Collins MR Gunnar Social and personality developmentAnnu Rev Psychol1990411387416

3 

C Singh DT Reddy Yoga Origin, History and Development in India2020https://yoga.ayush.gov.in/Yoga-History/

4 

D Thompson-Ochoa Is yoga cultural appropriation?Yoga Mimamsa2019513410.4103/ym.ym_5_19

5 

SV Bapat Psychophysiological analysis of Kriya Yoga as per Patanjali Yoga Sutra.Yoga Mimamsa20164811810.4103/0044-0507.198701

6 

I Anusic U Schimmack Stability and change of personality traits, self-esteem, and well-being: Introducing the meta-analytic stability and change model of retest correlationsJ Pers Soc Psychol2016110576681

7 

AB Bhavanani Diverse dimensions of yoga.Yoga Mimamsa201446138

8 

KU Dhungel BK Dahal The Mind-stuff" as a Cognitive Apparatus: Model of mind and process of cognition as in Yogasutra of PatanjaliJ Med Sci201431106

9 

RS Bhogal Exploring interventional authenticity in yoga research.Yoga Mimamsa2016481110.4103/0044-0507.198700

10 

SR Pandi-Perumal DW Spence N Srivastava D Kanchibhotla K Kumar GS Sharma The Origin and Clinical Relevance of Yoga NidraSleep Vigil2022616184

11 

N Chaudhry RB Bhandari V Gaur Yoga perspective on personal excellence and well-beingJ Ayurveda Integr Med202314310071710.1016/j.jaim.2023.100717

12 

VN Mishra N Mishra Management of emotions: a study using Patanjali's Yoga SutraInt J Bus Emer Mark201461318

13 

A Ramanujapuram Patanjali Yoga Sutras in the Light of Medical Neuroscience201810.13140/RG.2.2.15616.48645

14 

D Wolf The Vedic personality inventory: A study of the GunasJ Indian Psycho19981626

15 

D P Goldberg P Williams A User's Guide to the General Health Questionnaire. Windsor: nferNelson1991

16 

L R Goldberg The structure of phenotypic personality traitsAmerican Psychologist19934812634

17 

D P Goldberg V F Hillier A scaled version of the General Health QuestionnairePsychol Med197991139184

18 

H Bhargav N Eiman N Jasti P More V Kumar B Holla Composition of yoga-philosophy based mental traits (Gunas) in major psychiatric disorders: A trans-diagnostic approachFrontiers in Psychology202314

19 

H Adhia H Nagendra B Mahadevan Impact of Yoga way of life on organizational performanceInternational Journal of Yoga201025566

20 

D Mekonnen A Mossie Clinical effects of yoga on asthmatic patients: a preliminary clinical trialEthiop J Health Sci2010202107119

21 

B Amaranth H R Nagendra S Deshpande Effect of integrated Yoga module on the personality of home guards in Bengaluru: A randomized control trialJournal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine201614447

22 

K K Bhattacharyya D Dobbs G Hueluer Mind-Body Practice, Personality Traits, and Cognitive Performance: A 10-Years Study in US AdultsGerontol Geriatr Med202282333721422108347523337214221083475

23 

Y Liao X Cheng W Chen X Peng The Influence of Physical Exercise on Adolescent Personality Traits: The Mediating Role of Peer Relationship and the Moderating Role of Parent-Child RelationshipFront Psychol202213889758889758

24 

S Deshpande H R Nagendra R Nagarathna A randomized control trial of the effect of yoga on Gunas (personality) and Self-esteem in normal healthy volunteersInt J Yoga2009211321

25 

S Deshpande H R Nagendra N Raghuram A randomized control trial of the effect of yoga on Gunas (personality) and Health in normal healthy volunteersInt J Yoga200811210

26 

A M Househam C T Peterson P J Mills D Chopra The Effects of Stress and Meditation on the Immune System, Human Microbiota, and Epigenetics. Adv Mind Body MedFall20173141025



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 14-08-2023

Accepted : 08-09-2023


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.jpmhh.2023.017


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 1874

PDF Downloaded: 674